Fear of breeding minorities and other Israeli ailments

by Yaniv Reich on October 27, 2009

Muzzlewatch’s Sydney Levy hits the nail on the head with respect to the stereotypical demographic fear-mongering Jews that routinely do when assessing the two main options facing Israel: end ethnicity based exclusivism or end Israel’s pretense to democracy.

“But let’s focus on the present. The question on the table [at the J Street conference], Is there a demographic threat?

The good news, says Dr. Goldscheider, is that in the context of the State of Israel, Arab minorities present no demographic threat unless we include the occupied territories and give the inhabitants there equal rights. Inclusion without equal rights leads to the end of democracy. Inclusion with equal rights leads to the end of the Jewish majority in the state. And that is why a two-state solution is a must: to preserve Jewish democracy.

The Palestinians are of course non-players in this Jewish democratic drama. At most, they are a threat just for being there. At best, they are a minority that we must keep under demographic control.
[…]
Now, I am Jewish and I am also a Latino man living in California–a state where we have a pluralistic demographic composition: not one group, not even non-Latino whites, amount to 50% of the population. If I were to hear white people bemoaning the demographic threat that the rise of people of color in the state represents, I would call it like it is, and that is racism, pure and simple. I have no use for the phrase demographic threat. It leaves a bad taste in my mouth and a sharp pain in my gut.

What we say matters a lot; that’s what we were told in this workshop. If we need to use racism to message ourselves as Pro-Israel pro-peace, there is something very wrong here.”

Related Posts:

Previous post:

Next post: